German steel import dependence could cost economy €50 billion annually

by David Fleschen

Germany could face annual economic losses of up to €50 billion if it became heavily dependent on imported steel and experienced a major disruption to international supplies. A study by economists at the University of Mannheim warns that abandoning domestic steel production could expose the country's manufacturing sector to substantial economic risks.

The research, funded by the Hans Böckler Foundation and published in November 2025, examines the consequences of a hypothetical global steel supply shock. Such a scenario could arise if major exporters, including China, sharply reduced shipments to Europe because of geopolitical tensions or supply chain disruptions.

According to the study's authors, economists Tom Krebs and Patrick Kaczmarczyk, the potential losses would amount to approximately 1.2% of Germany's gross domestic product.

Domestic production seen as essential for supply security

The researchers challenge the argument that Germany could reduce industrial costs by relying predominantly on imported steel.

While foreign producers may offer lower prices under normal market conditions, the study argues that such comparisons often overlook the economic consequences of disrupted supply chains.

A major supply shock would increase steel costs for downstream industries, including automotive manufacturing, mechanical engineering, construction and electrical equipment production.

The researchers estimate that approximately half of the potential €50 billion annual loss would result from higher input costs and reduced industrial output. The remainder would arise from falling household incomes and weaker domestic demand.

The study therefore argues that maintaining domestic steelmaking capacity should be regarded not only as an industrial policy objective but also as a form of economic risk management.

Major investment gap in low-carbon primary steel

Krebs and Kaczmarczyk estimate that European steel demand could remain between 160 million and 180 million tonnes annually through 2050.

To maintain a resilient supply structure, they recommend preserving at least 40 million tonnes of annual steel production in Germany, divided approximately equally between primary steel and scrap-based secondary production.

However, the researchers identify a substantial gap between the capacity required for low-carbon primary steelmaking and current investment plans.

According to their calculations, Germany would need approximately 20 million tonnes of annual primary steel capacity based on lower-emission production technologies. Projects currently planned would provide only around eight million tonnes.

The shortfall reflects, among other developments, ArcelorMittal's decision not to proceed with its previously announced transformation investments in Bremen and Eisenhüttenstadt, as well as the limited scope of current plans at thyssenkrupp's Duisburg operations.

The study also highlights the approaching end of the technical operating life of Germany's existing coke-based blast furnaces, which the authors expect to reach this point by 2035.

They argue that investment in direct reduction technology must therefore accelerate if Germany is to retain substantial primary steel production while reducing emissions.

Imported iron ore does not eliminate supply risks

The researchers also address the argument that domestic steelmaking offers limited strategic independence because Germany already imports the iron ore required for primary production.

They distinguish between raw material imports and dependence on finished steel products.

According to the study, iron ore is traded through comparatively diversified international markets, whereas steel supply chains involve different production structures, capacities and potential bottlenecks.

The authors are similarly sceptical about relocating large parts of European steel production to countries with potentially cheaper renewable energy.

Although southern European locations may offer advantages in electricity generation, the researchers argue that splitting interconnected production processes across multiple countries could introduce additional transport requirements, energy consumption and supply chain risks.

Employment consequences extend beyond steelworks

The study also examines the potential social consequences of a substantial decline in German steel production.

Of approximately 70,000 employees in the sector at the time of the study, 42% were over 50 years old. The researchers estimate that at least 30,000 workers could face particularly difficult employment prospects if domestic production were largely relocated abroad.

The impact would be concentrated in established steelmaking regions, including Duisburg, Bremen, Eisenhüttenstadt, Salzgitter and Saarland.

Beyond direct employment, the researchers point to the importance of steel for downstream manufacturing. Around four million people work in German industries that use steel as a major input.

The authors conclude that supporting the transition towards low-carbon domestic steel production could serve two objectives simultaneously: reducing industrial emissions and strengthening economic resilience.

Source: Hans Böckler Stiftung, Photo: Fotolia