German steel summit highlights energy costs and growing pressure on industry
by David Fleschen
Germany's steel industry has renewed its demands for competitive electricity prices, stronger trade protection and reliable markets for low-emission steel. At the National Steel Summit in Salzgitter on November 16, industry representatives, trade unions and regional governments presented a joint position paper to Federal Economics Minister Katherina Reiche, calling for more decisive political action to safeguard domestic steel production.
Hosted by Salzgitter AG in Lower Saxony, the summit brought together representatives from eleven German steel-producing states, the industry association Wirtschaftsvereinigung Stahl and trade union IG Metall. Discussions focused on the economic conditions required to maintain steel production in Germany while financing the transition towards climate-neutral manufacturing.
Outside the venue, more than 2,000 steelworkers demonstrated against high energy costs and international competitive pressures. Reiche faced criticism from employees who questioned whether government measures would provide sufficient relief.
Electricity prices remain central concern
The joint position paper identifies electricity costs as one of the principal obstacles to competitive low-emission steel production. Although Germany has introduced measures to reduce industrial energy costs, industry representatives argue that electricity prices remain too high compared with competing production locations.
Reiche defended the government's record, pointing to the introduction of an industrial electricity price despite resistance at European level.
"We have an industrial electricity price for the first time, and we fought for it against considerable opposition from Brussels," she said.
Gunnar Groebler, CEO of Salzgitter AG and President of Wirtschaftsvereinigung Stahl, acknowledged progress on trade protection but warned against weakening existing measures through international negotiations.
He also stressed that the industry's transformation was no longer merely a future ambition. Billions of euros have already been invested, new facilities are entering operation and lower-emission steel products are reaching the market.
However, Groebler argued that these investments must be accompanied by sufficient demand and competitive electricity prices, not only for steelmakers but for energy-intensive industry as a whole.
Calls for European steel in public procurement
Another central demand was the establishment of lead markets capable of creating reliable demand for steel produced under stricter environmental standards.
Lower Saxony's Minister-President Olaf Lies argued that public investment in infrastructure, automotive manufacturing and offshore wind energy should increasingly benefit European steel producers.
"If we want steel from Europe, we must also be prepared to use it," Lies said.
Bernd Lange, Chair of the European Parliament's International Trade Committee, pointed to ongoing discussions about European procurement rules and possible incentives for the use of low-emission steel in automotive manufacturing.
The debate reflects a growing concern that European steelmakers may invest heavily in cleaner production technologies without securing sufficient customers willing to pay the associated additional costs.
Different views on the future of German steelmaking
The summit took place against a difficult backdrop for the German steel industry. High energy costs, international overcapacity and competition from lower-cost producers continue to put pressure on domestic manufacturers.
The transformation towards hydrogen-based steel production presents additional challenges, particularly regarding the availability and price of low-emission hydrogen.
Salzgitter's SALCOS programme illustrates the scale of the investment involved in replacing conventional blast furnace production with lower-carbon technologies.
However, the long-term competitiveness of primary steelmaking in Germany remains contested. A recent analysis by consultancy PwC questioned whether conventional blast furnace production could remain economically viable and suggested a stronger focus on scrap-based electric arc furnace steelmaking and internationally sourced intermediate products.
This contrasts with the position of industry representatives and regional governments, who emphasise the strategic importance of maintaining domestic steel production capacity.
Steelworkers demand greater certainty
IG Metall Deputy Chairman Jürgen Kerner reaffirmed the union's support for the transition to climate-neutral steel production but warned that uncertainty among employees was increasing.
He attributed this partly to inconsistent signals from policymakers and company management, calling for clearer commitments on the industry's future.
Around 80,000 people are directly employed in German steel production, while approximately four million work in steel-intensive industries, according to Wirtschaftsvereinigung Stahl.
Photo: Salzgitter